| 2013 | G | Nicole Barnhart | FC Kansas City | |
| D | Christie Rampone | Sky Blue FC | ||
| D | Leigh Ann Robinson | FC Kansas City | ||
| D | Becky Sauerbrunn | FC Kansas City | ||
| D | Brittany Taylor | Western New York Flash | ||
| M | Lori Chalupny | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| M | Lauren Cheney/Holiday | FC Kansas City | ||
| M | Jessica Fishlock | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| M | Diana Matheson | Washington Spirit | ||
| F | Sydney Leroux | Boston Breakers | ||
| F | Abby Wambach | Western New York Flash |
| 2013 | G | Adrianna Franch | Western New York Flash | |
| D | Rachel Buehler | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| D | Caitlin Foord | Sky Blue FC | ||
| D | Ali Krieger | Washington Spirit | ||
| D | Lauren Sesselmann | FC Kansas City | ||
| M | Megan Rapinoe | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| M | Desiree Scott | FC Kansas City | ||
| M | Erika Tymrak | FC Kansas City | ||
| M | Lianne Sanderson | Boston Breakers | ||
| F | Alex Morgan | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| F | Christine Sinclair | Portland Thorns FC |
| 2014 | G | Alyssa Naeher | Boston Breakers | |
| D | Kendall Fletcher | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| D | Ali Krieger | Washington Spirit | ||
| D | Christie Rampone | Sky Blue FC | ||
| D | Becky Sauerbrunn | FC Kansas City | ||
| M | Veronica Boquete | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| M | Jessica Fishlock | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| M | Kim Little | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| F | Lauren Holiday | FC Kansas City | ||
| F | Nahomi Kawasumi | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| F | Amy Rodriguez | FC Kansas City |
| 2014 | G | Hope Solo | Seattle Reign FC | |
| D | Lauren Barnes | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| D | Stephanie Catley | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| D | Stephanie Cox | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| D | Julie Johnston | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| M | Carli Lloyd | Western New York Flash | ||
| M | Allie Long | Portland ThornsFC | ||
| M | Heather O'Reilly | Boston Breakers | ||
| F | Jessica McDonald | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| F | Christen Press | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| F | Jodie Taylor | Washington Spirit |
| 2015 | G | Michelle Betos | Portland Thorns FC | |
| D | Lauren Barnes | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| D | Julie Johnston | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| D | Amy LePeilet | FC Kansas City | ||
| D | Becky Sauerbrunn | FC Kansas City | ||
| M | Jessica Fishlock | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| M | Kim Little | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| M | Allie Long | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| F | Crystal Dunn | Washington Spirit | ||
| F | Christen Press | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| F | Beverly Yanez | Seatte Reign FC |
| 2015 | G | Nicole Barnhart | FC Kansas City | |
| D | Stephanie Cox | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| D | Kendall Fletcher | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| D | Arin Gilliland | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| D | Leigh Ann Robinson | FC Kansas City | ||
| M | Danielle Colaprico | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| M | Lauren Holiday | FC Kansas City | ||
| M | Carli Lloyd | Houston Dash | ||
| M | Keelin Winters | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| F | Sofia Huerta | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| F | Megan Rapinoe | Seattle Reign FC |
| 2016 | G | Ashlyn Harris | Orlando Pride | |
| D | Lauren Barnes | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| D | Arin Gilliland | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| D | Emily Menges | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| D | Becky Sauerbrunn | FC Kansas City | ||
| M | Tobin Heath | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| M | Allie Long | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| F | Jessica McDonald | Western New York Flash | ||
| F | Kealia Ohai | Houston Dash | ||
| F | Christen Press | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| F | Lynn Williams | Western New York Flash |
| 2016 | G | Alyssa Naeher | Chicago Red Stars | |
| D | Julie Johnson | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| D | Ali Krieger | Washington Spirit | ||
| D | Christie Rampone | Sky Blue FC | ||
| D | Casey Short | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| M | Danielle Colaprico | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| M | Vanessa DiBernardo | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| M | Jessica Fishlock | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| M | Kim Little | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| F | Crystal Dunn | Washington Spirit | ||
| F | Shea Groom | FC Kansas City |
| 2017 | G | Adrianna Franch | Portlnad Thorns FC | |
| D | Abby Dahlkemper | North Carolina Courage | ||
| D | Ali Krieger | Orlando Pride | ||
| D | Becky Sauerbrunn | FC Kansas City | ||
| D | Casey Short | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| M | Jessica Fishlock | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| M | Samantha Mewis | North Carolina Courage | ||
| M | McCall Zerboni | North Carolina Courage | ||
| F | Samantha Kerr | Sky Blue FC | ||
| F | Marta | Orlando Pride | ||
| F | Christen Press | Chicago Red Stars |
| 2017 | G | Katelyn Rowland | North Carolina Courage | |
| D | Stephanie Catley | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| D | Abby Erceg | North Carolina Courage | ||
| D | Meghan Klingenberg | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| D | Emily Menges | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| M | Danielle Colaprico | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| M | Julie Ertz | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| M | Lindsey Horan | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| M | Sofia Huerta | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| F | Alex Morgan | Orlando Pride | ||
| F | Megan Rapinoe | Seattle Reign FC |
| 2018 | G | Adrianna Franch | Portland Thorns FC | |
| D | Abby Dahlkemper | North Carolina Courage | ||
| D | Abby Erceg | North Carolina Courage | ||
| D | Becky Sauerbrunn | Utah Royals FC | ||
| D | Emily Sonnett | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| M | Tobin Heath | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| M | Lindsey Horan | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| M | McCall Zerboni | North Carolina Courage | ||
| F | Crystal Dunn | North Carolina Courage | ||
| F | Samantha Kerr | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| F | Megan Rapinoe | Seattle Reign FC |
| 2018 | G | Lydia Williams | Seattle Reign FC | |
| D | Stephanie Catley | Seattle Reign FC | ||
| D | Julie Ertz | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| D | Merritt Mathias | North Carolina Courage | ||
| D | Emily Menges | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| M | Debinha | North Carolina Courage | ||
| M | Carli Lloyd | Sky Blue FC | ||
| M | Christine Sinclair | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| F | Rachel Daly | Houston Dash | ||
| F | Sofia Huerta | Red Stars/Dash | ||
| F | Lynn Williams | North Carolina Courage |
| 2019 | G | Aubrey Bledsoe | Washington Spirit | |
| D | Abby Dahlkemper | North Carolina Courage | ||
| D | Ali Krieger | Orlando Pride | ||
| D | Becky Sauerbrunn | Utah Royals FC | ||
| D | Casey Short | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| M | Julie Ertz | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| M | Lindsey Horan | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| M | Rose Lavelle | Washington Spirit | ||
| F | Tobin Heath | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| F | Samantha Kerr | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| F | Christen Press | Utah Royals FC |
| 2019 | G | Alyssa Naeher | Chicago Red Stars | |
| D | Lauren Barnes | OL Reign | ||
| D | Abby Erceg | North Carolina Courage | ||
| D | Kelley O'Hara | Utah Royals FC | ||
| D | Emily Sonnett | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| M | Bethany Balcer | OL Reign | ||
| M | Crystal Dunn | North Carolina Courage | ||
| M | Yuki Nagasato | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| F | Kristen Hamilton | North Carolina Courage | ||
| F | Carli Lloyd | Sky Blue FC | ||
| F | Megan Rapinoe | OL Reign |
| 2021 | G | Kailen Sheridan | NJ/NY Gotham FC | |
| D | Alana Cook | OL Reign | ||
| D | Caprice Dydasco | NJ/NY Gotham FC | ||
| D | Sarah Gorden | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| D | Carson Pickett | North Carolina Courage | ||
| M | Jessica Fishlock | OL Reign | ||
| M | Eugenie Le Sommer | OL Reign | ||
| M | Angela Salem | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| F | Ashley Hatch | Washington Spirit | ||
| F | Midge Purce | NJ/NY Gotham FC | ||
| F | Trinity Rodman | Washington Spirit |
| 2021 | G | Bella Bixby | Portland Thorns FC | |
| D | Emily Fox | Racing Louisville FC | ||
| D | Sofia Huerta | OL Reign | ||
| D | Meghan Klingenberg | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| D | Emily Menges | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| M | Lindsay Horan | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| M | Mallory Pugh | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| F | Bethany Balcer | OL Reign | ||
| F | Rachel Daly | Houston Dash | ||
| F | Sydney Leroux | Orlando Pride | ||
| F | Ifeoma Onumonu | NJ/NJ Gotham FC |
| 2022 | G | Kailen Sheridan | San Diego Wave FC | |
| D | Alana Cook | OL Reign | ||
| D | Naomi Girma | San Diego Wave FC | ||
| D | Sofia Huerta | OL Reign | ||
| D | Carson Pickett | North Carolina Courage | ||
| M/F | Samantha Coffey | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| M/F | Debinha | North Carolina Courage | ||
| M/F | Lo'eau LaBonta | Kansas City Current | ||
| M/F | Alex Morgan | San Diego Wave FC | ||
| M/F | Mallory Pugh | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| M/F | Sophia Smith | Portland Thorns FC |
| 2022 | G | Adrianna Franch | Kansas City Current | |
| D | Kelli Hubly | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| D | Hailie Mace | Kansas City Current | ||
| D | Tatumn Milazzo | Chicago Red Stars | ||
| D | Becky Sauerbrunn | Portland Thorns FC | ||
| M/F | Jessica Fishlock | OL Reign | ||
| M/F | Kerolin | North Carolina Courage | ||
| M/F | Rose Lavelle | OL Reign | ||
| M/F | Diana Ordonez | North Carolina Courage | ||
| M/F | Megan Rapinoe | OL Reign | ||
| M/F | Ebony Salmon | Racing Louisville FC |
| Multiple winning goalkeepers: Adrianna Franch and Kailen Sheridan (2) |
|---|
| Consecutive winning goalkeepers: Adrianna Franch and Kailen Sheridan (2) |
| Multiple winning defenders: Becky Sauerbrunn (7); Ali Krieger and Abby Dahlkemper (3); Christie Rampone, Lauren Barnes, Casey Short, Alana Cook, and Carson Pickett (2) |
| Consecutive winning defenders: Becky Sauerbrunn (7); Abby Dahlkemper (3); Christie Rampone, Lauren Barnes, Alana Cook, and Carson Pickett (2) |
| Multiple winning midfielders: Jessica Fishlock (4); Kim Little, Allie Long, Tobin Heath, McCall Zerboni, Julie Johnston/Ertz, and Lindsey Horan (2) |
| Consecutive winning midfielders: Jessica Fishlock (3); Kim Little, Allie Long, McCall Zerboni, and Lindsey Horan (2) |
| Multiple winning forwards: Christen Press (4); Samantha Kerr (3) |
| Consecutive winning forwards: Christen Press and Samantha Kerr (3) |
| Multiple winners at multiple positions: Tobin Heath (3); Lauren Cheney/Holiday (2) |
| Consecutive winners at multiple positions: Lauren Cheney/Holiday and Tobin Heath (2) |
| G | D | M | F | M/F | TOT | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Seattle Reign FC/OL Reign | 0 | 4 | 8 | 3 | 0 | 17 |
| 2. | Portland Thorns FC | 3 | 2 | 8 | 1 | 2 | 17 |
| 3. | Western New York Flash/North Carolina Courage | 0 | 7 | 3 | 4 | 1 | 15 |
| 4. | Chicago Red Stars | 0 | 5 | 2 | 5 | 1 | 13 |
| 5. | FC Kansas City | 1 | 7 | 1 | 2 | 0 | 11 |
| 6. | Washington Spirit | 1 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 0 | 7 |
| 7. | Sky Blue FC-NJ/NY Gotham FC | 1 | 3 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 6 |
| 8. | Orlando Pride | 1 | 2 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 4 |
| 9. | Utah Royals FC | 0 | 2 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 3 |
| 10. | San Diego Wave FC | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 3 |
| 11. | Boston Breakers | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 2 |
| 12. | Houston Dash | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 1 |
| Active teams without Best XI selection: Kansas City Current (2021); Racing Louisville FC (2021); Angel City FC (2022) | |||||||