| YEAR | REGULAR SEASON | MLS PLAYOFFS | US OPEN CUP | CONCACAF | OTHER |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1996 | 15-17 (6-2 SO), 33 pts 5th of 5 (Eastern) |
did not qualify | did not enter | not eligible | none |
| 1997 | 15-17 (4-4 SO), 37 pts 4th of 5 (Eastern) |
Eastern Semifinals (R8) l. D.C. United |
Third Round (R16) l. Long Island Rough Riders |
did not qualify | none |
| 1998 | 11-21 (2-4 SO), 29 pts 6th of 6 (Eastern) |
did not qualify | did not enter | did not qualify | none |
| 1999 | 12-20 (5-7 SO), 26 pts 5th of 6 (Eastern) |
did not qualify | did not enter | did not qualify | none |
| YEAR | REGULAR SEASON | MLS PLAYOFFS | US OPEN CUP | CONCACAF | OTHER |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2000 | 13-13-6, 45 pts 2nd of 4 (East) |
1st Round (R8) l. Chicago Fire |
Second Round (R32) l. Mid Michigan Bucks |
did not qualify | none |
| 2001 | 7-14-6, 27 pts 3rd of 4 (East0 |
did not qualify | Finalist l. Los Angeles Galaxy |
did not qualify | none |
| 2002 | 12-14-2, 38 pts 1st of 5 (Eastern) |
MLS Cup l. Los Angeles Galaxy |
did not enter | did not qualify | none |
| 2003 | 12-9-9, 45 pts 2nd of 5 (Eastern) |
Eastern Championship l. Chicago Fire |
Quarterfinals l. MetroStars |
1/8 Finals l. LD Alajuelense |
none |
| 2004 | 8-13-9, 33 pts 4th of 5 (Eastern) |
Eastern Championship l. D.C. United |
Fourth Round (R16) l. Rochester Raging Rhinos |
did not qualify | none |
| 2005 | 17-7-8, 59 pts 1st of 6 (Eastern) |
MLS Cup l. Los Angeles Galaxy |
Fourth Round (R16) l. Chicago Fire |
did not qualify | none |
| 2006 | 12-8-12, 48 pts 2nd of 6 (Eastern) |
MLS Cup l. Houston Dynamo |
Quarterfinals l. Chicago Fire |
Quarterfinals l. LD Alajuelense |
none |
| 2007 | 14-8-8, 50 pts 2nd of 7 (Eastern) |
MLS Cup l. Houston Dynamo |
U.S. Open Cup Champions d. FC Dallas |
did not qualify | none |
| 2008 | 12-11-7, 43 pts 3rd of 7 (Eastern) |
Eastern Semifinals (R8) l. Chicago Fire |
Semifinals l. D.C. United |
did not qualify | none |
| 2009 | 11-10-9, 42 pts 3rd of 7 (Eastern) |
Eastern Semifinals (R8) l. Chicago Fire |
Third Round (R16) l. Harrisburg City Islanders |
Preliminary l. Joe Public FC |
none |
| YEAR | REGULAR SEASON | MLS PLAYOFFS | US OPEN CUP | CONCACAF | OTHER |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2010 | 9-16-5, 32 pts 6th of 8 (Eastern) |
did not qualify | Qualifying l. New York Red Bulls |
did not qualify | none |
| 2011 | 5-16-13, 28 pts 9th of 9 (Eastern) |
did not qualify | Qualifying l. Sporting Kansas City |
did not qualify | none |
| 2012 | 9-17-8, 35 pts 9th of 10 (Eastern) |
did not qualify | Third Round (R32) l. Harrisburg City Islanders |
did not qualify | none |
| 2013 | 14-11-9, 51 pts 3rd of 10 (Eastern) |
Eastern Semifinals (R8) l. Sporting Kansas City |
Quarterfinals l. D.C. United |
did not qualify | none |
| 2014 | 17-13-4, 55 pts 2nd of 10 (Eastern) |
MLS Cup l. Los Angeles Galaxy |
Quarterfinals l. Philadelphia Union |
did not qualify | none |
| 2015 | 14-12-8, 50 pts 5th of 10 (Eastern) |
Eastern Wild Card (R12) l. D.C. United |
Fourth Round (R32) l. Charlotte Independence |
did not qualify | none |
| 2016 | 11-14-9, 42 pts 7th of 10 (Eastern) |
did not qualify | Finalist l. FC Dallas |
did not qualify | none |
| 2017 | 13-15-6, 45 pts 7th of 11 (Eastern) |
did not qualify | Quarterfinals l. New York Red Bulls |
did not qualify | none |
| 2018 | 10-13-11, 41 pts 8th of 11 (Eastern) |
did not qualify | Fourth Round (R32) l. Louisville City FC |
did not qualify | none |
| 2019 | 11-11-12, 45 pts 7th of 12 (Eastern) |
Eastern First Round (R14) l. Atlanta United FC |
Fifth Round (R16) l. Orlando City SC |
did not qualify | none |
| YEAR | REGULAR SEASON | MLS PLAYOFFS | US OPEN CUP | CONCACAF | OTHER |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 | 8-7-8, 32 pts 8th of 14 (Eastern) |
Eastern Final (R4) l. Columbus Crew SC |
tournament cancelled | did not qualify | MLS Is Back (R16) l. Philadelphia Union |
| 2021 | 22-5-7, 73 pts 1st of 14 (Eastern) |
Eastern Semifinals (R8) l. New York City FC |
tournament cancelled | did not qualify | none |
| 2022 | 10-12-12, 42 pts 10th of 14 (Eastern) |
did not qualify | Fifth Round (R16) l. New York City FC |
Quartefinals l. Pumas UNAM |
none |
| 2023 | 15-9-10, 55 pts 5th of 15 (Eastern) |
Eastern First Round (R16) l. Philadelphia Union |
Fourth Round (R32) l. Pittsburgh Riverhounds SC |
did not qualify | Leagues (R16) l. Queretaro |
| 2024 | Quarterfinals l. Club America |